Home » Site News » Gaia Online:Is Integral Gov...

Gaia Online:Is Integral Government an Oligarchy?

Tags :     

I tend to have a love/hate relationship with Integral and Ken Wilber (this is often apparent in my blog and my comments on threads). I've read and even re-read many of Ken's books and I feel he definitely has insight into many domains of thought.

However, the 'values' contained within the hierarchy this system or 'map' advocates has always been a bone of contention for me.


Nevertheless, I often read the discussions posted on the Integral Pod and feel that most of what is posted is highly informative as far as the Integral 'map' is concerned.

Yet, recently I have become remarkably interested in the Pod authority's decisions to summarily remove members. Keep in mind, to become a member of this pod one must seek an invitation f Aion the moderators by demonstrating that you are "sincerely excited about" the Integral Theory (obviously, this is why I have not sought out membership and why I would most likely NOT be included).

If you go into the "announcements and feedback" section of the discussions you will notice two topics one labeled "Removed member" and another entitled "Another member about to be removed?"

However, above those topics you will find a topic entitled "An important Announcement about the pod" in which at the beginning of this thread the moderator delineates in very clear statements the "vision" for the direction of the pod in which all the "moderators" have agreed. Here is a very poignant quote in relation to that pod's "vision":

"There comes a time when communities reach a bifurcation point, or a crisis of some kind, where hard decisions have to be made. We have already made one such decision with removing Rick. It was absolutely necessary for the health of the pod, and we are going to be making more decisions that are unpopular with some people. This pod was created with a vision in mind, which has not changed in any essential way." [my bold]


In addition, with respect to other ideas or "information" [READ: nonconforming] this 'moderating' authority explains:


This is not to say that we are closed to new information or ideas. However, there comes a time when decisions have to be made, and we will make them, without apology or rancor, as we have the full authority to do. This has been explained clearly and unequivocably. Anyone who fails to understand this should leave now. Any further discussion of our right to do this will be dealt with as a direct violation of the rules of this pod.


Note how any discussion against this totalistic viewpoint (which has not been made clear and thus is possibly 'secret') is considered a violation of the pod rules. And, in relation to the "health of the pod," which is emphasized repeatedly:


"It is only in extreme situations that we as mods consider cutting off discussions. Essentially, we have to believe that the pod is in danger of being deeply harmed by further discussion, and that there is no amicable solution to a problem possible. This is such a time...These are not actions we have taken lightly or precipitously. In spite of our frustration at times, the health of the pod has always remained uppermost in our minds-ahead of our egos and any emotions we have had."

 

It seems that here we have "Integral government" exemplified, which in form appears no different than many current systems which easily disenfranchise individuals and groups not in complinace with that status quo. This form of governing is often referred to as an "oligarchy" in which governing power rests with a small, elite segment of society or "the rule of the few." Notice the disclaimers which exist throughout the statements as to the validity of the choices made. I find this to be very disturbing and historically reminiscent.

Obviously, the originators of this pod have the right to govern or control their members as they choose. I just assumed that with the popularity and seemingly transcendent status of the "Integral Theory" some other more integrative method would be employed to maintain order/control (and I find it remarkable that so much control is necessary in the first place!).

Nevertheless, it seems the integral map provides no means of enlightened governance other than the obvious methods which have prevailed throughout history and have resulted in much pain and suffering.

And if the 'map' fails to establish parameters through which a more 'enlightened' government can exist, so as to allow its constituents/citizens the freedom to seek Spirit in a free and unencumbered social order, then as a collective we will be no better off than we are now.
 

Guild Wars 2
Buy Gold
Buy PowerLeveling
Buy CDKey
Aion
Aion Gold
Aion PowerLeveling
Aion Card
Atlantica
Atlantica Gold
Atlantica PowerLeveling
Atlantica Items
Nexon Cash Code
Blade and Soul
Buy Gold
Buy PowerLeveling
Buy CDKey
C9: Golden Continent
Buy Gold
Dragon's Prophet
Buy Gold
Buy Items
Buy CDKey
Metin2
Metin2 Gold
Star Wars: The Old Republic
Buy Gold
Buy PowerLeveling
Buy Time Card
Anarchy
Anarchy Gold
Anarchy Items
Anarchy CDKey
ArcheAge
ArcheAge Gold
ArcheAge PowerLeveling
ArcheAge Items
ArcheAge CDKey
ASTA
ASTA Gold
Black Desert
Buy Gold
Cabal
Cabal Gold
Cabal PowerLeveling
Cabal Cash
DC Universe Online
Buy Gold
Dekaron
Dekaron Gold
Digimon Masters Online
Buy Gold
Dofus
Dofus Gold
Dofus Items
Dragon Nest
Buy Gold
Buy PowerLeveling
Buy Items
Nexon Cash Code
Dungeon Fighter Online
Buy Gold
Buy PowerLeveling
Eden Eternal
Buy Gold
ELOA
ELOA Gold
ELSword
ELSword Gold
Eve
Eve Gold
Eve Time Card
FFXI
FFXI Gold
FFXI CDKey
FFXIV
FFXIV Gold
Fiesta
Fiesta Gold
GrandFantasia
Buy Gold
Habbo
Habbo Gold
Habbo CDKey
Kingdom Under Fire II SEA
Buy Gold
Knight
Knight Gold
LastChaos
LastChaos Gold
Lotro
Lotro Gold
Lotro PowerLeveling
Mabinogi
Mabinogi Gold
Mabinogi Items
Nexon Cash Code
Maple Story
Buy Gold
Nexon Cash Code
MU Legend
MU Legend Gold
NeverWinter Online
Buy Gold
Ragnarok
Ragnarok Gold
Ragnarok Items
Ragnarok2
Ragnarok2 Gold
RF
RF Gold
RF Items
Riders of Icarus
Buy Gold
Buy PowerLeveling
Buy Items
Buy CDKey
Rose
Rose Gold
Runes Of Magic
RuneScape
RuneScape Gold
RuneScape PowerLeveling
RuneScape Account
Shaiya
Shaiya Gold
Shaiya PowerLeveling
Shaiya Items
Aeria Points
SilkRoad
SilkRoad Gold
SilkRoad Items
Silkroad Silk
SilkRoad R
SilkRoad R Gold
SilkRoad R CDKey
SoulSaver
SoulSaver Gold
Star_Trek
Star_Trek Gold
Swords of Legends Online
Buy Gold
The Elder Scrolls Online
Buy Gold
Buy PowerLeveling
Buy CDKey
The Secret World
Buy Gold
Buy CDKey
Tibia
Tibia Gold
Torchlight2
Buy Gold
Uncharted Waters Online
Buy Gold
Vindictus
Vindictus Gold
Vindictus PowerLeveling
Vindictus Items
Nexon Cash Code
Wakfu
Wakfu Gold
Wildstar
Wildstar Gold
Wildstar PowerLeveling
Wildstar CDKey